Skip to main content

Your Cart

Your cart is currently empty.
Click here to continue shopping.

Thrift Shopping Tips: How I Thrift With a Wishlist (The Thrifted Edit, Vol. 01)

Two thrifted outfits: a utility shirt with black wide-leg trousers, and a white button-down with light jeans

The Joy of Getting Dressed Again · The Thrifted Edit, Vol. 01 · By Lyanne Loriz

Shop your closet first. Then thrift with a list.

The short answer: to thrift with a wishlist, shop your own closet first and write down what is missing. At the thrift store, keep an open mind and try everything on, because sizes vary from brand to brand. Do a quick round just for fit, then try the pieces that fit again and build outfits.

In Chapter 1, I shopped my own closet. It showed me what I actually wear, and it showed me what was missing. So I took that list and went thrifting with my daughter.

This is The Thrifted Edit, Vol. 01: how I thrift, what I tried on, what came home and what stayed behind. It is the start of a series inside The Joy of Getting Dressed Again, all about shopping secondhand with intention.

Thrift haul on a clothing rack: golden faux fur jacket, cream knit cardigan, denim midi skirt, black and khaki wide-leg trousers, white button-up and taupe utility shirt
Everything from one thrift trip, ready to mix with what I already own.

Why Shop Secondhand First?

In our house, we never buy seasonal clothes new. We always try secondhand first. A holiday sweater or a cozy layer is usually worn only a handful of times, and someone else has already let it go. It is also one of the simplest ways to buy less and still have fun getting dressed.

My Thrift Shopping Tips: 5 Rules I Always Follow

1

Go with a wishlist.

Shopping my closet first told me exactly what I was looking for, so I was not just filling a cart.

2

Keep an open mind and try everything on.

You cannot always tell how something will fit on a hanger, and you come across so many brands that fit by size is different every time.

3

Try more than one size.

I am a small in tops, but I try S to L because sometimes I like a looser fit.

4

Do two rounds.

First I quickly try things on and take them off, just for fit. Then I try the pieces that fit again and make outfits.

5

Focus on one person per trip.

My daughter and I have a deal. When we go thrifting, we focus on one person. This trip was mine, so she knew what I was looking for and helped me find pieces to try that were about my size. Once we are done, we might grab a few things for the other person.

What I Tried On at the Thrift Store

Thrift store fitting room try-ons: khaki wide-leg trousers with a black tee, a leopard midi skirt, a denim midi skirt and a utility shirt with black pants
A few of the many things I tried on.

I tried on a lot. Wide-leg khaki trousers, a silk leopard midi skirt, a denim midi skirt, a utility shirt and more. Most things come off as fast as they go on. That is the point of the first round.

What Came Home: My Thrift Haul

Thrift haul flat lay: black trousers, cream knit cardigan, golden faux fur jacket, denim midi skirt, khaki trousers, taupe utility shirt and white button-up
The whole haul, laid out.
  • A cropped utility shirt in soft taupe
  • Black wide-leg trousers
  • A light denim midi skirt
  • A white button-up shirt
  • Khaki wide-leg trousers
  • A golden faux fur jacket
  • A cream knit cardigan

And for my daughter, once my list was done: a super cute, super soft bear ear sweater and holiday pink pants.

What Stayed Behind

The silk leopard midi skirt stayed at the store. Not every great piece needs to come home. If it is not on the list and does not work with what I already own, it is easier to let it go.

How to Style a Thrifted Utility Shirt Two Ways

The utility shirt was my favorite find, because it works with so much of what I already have.

Lyanne smiling in a thrifted cropped utility shirt and thrifted black wide-leg trousers
Buttoned up with the black wide-leg trousers.
Lyanne laughing in a thrifted utility shirt worn open over a black crop top with a light denim midi skirt
Open over a black crop top with the denim midi skirt.

Buttoned up with the black trousers, it feels polished and easy. Worn open over a black crop top with the denim skirt, it feels relaxed and a little playful. Same shirt, two different days, and both feel like me. If you are building a sustainable wardrobe without starting over, this is the kind of piece to look for.

The Thrifted White Button-Down (Tags Still On)

Lyanne walking on a sunny Miami sidewalk in a thrifted white button-down, light jeans, white sneakers and a black crossbody bag
Thrifted white button-down with jeans, sneakers and a bag I already had.

This one still had the tags on. You can never go wrong with a white button-down. I wear it loose and a little oversized, sleeves rolled, with light jeans, my everyday sneakers and a crossbody bag. It is the easiest way to look put together on a regular errand day, and it will work just as well tucked into the black trousers or over the denim skirt.

Thrifting With Kids: Our One-Person Rule

Lyanne and her daughter, who wears her thrifted fuzzy bear ear sweater
Her thrifted bear ear sweater was the find of the day.

The best part of thrifting is doing it together. She helped me find pieces in my size, and she came home with the softest bear ear sweater. We even put our new thrifted sweaters on over the outfits from our dance party video.

Shopping for the holidays? Secondhand counts. My buy-less gift guide includes a preloved vintage Levi's jacket and simple gifts that actually get used, and every gift order can come with a handwritten note.

Follow along with me. I am sharing every Thrifted Edit and every chapter of The Joy of Getting Dressed Again by email, plus a free Your Three Words printable to help you start.

Honest posts about style and real life. Unsubscribe anytime.

Thrift Shopping FAQ

How do you thrift with a wishlist?

Shop your own closet first and write down what you would actually wear and do not have. Bring that list to the thrift store so you look for specific pieces instead of filling a cart with things that do not work with your wardrobe.

Should you try on clothes at the thrift store?

Yes. You cannot always tell how something will fit on a hanger, and secondhand racks mix many brands with different sizing. Do a quick round to check fit, then try the pieces that fit again to build outfits.

What size should I look for when thrifting?

Look beyond your usual size. Sizing changes from brand to brand, so try one size up and down. If you like a looser fit in tops, try a few sizes larger.

Is it better to go thrifting alone or with someone?

Going with someone helps if you agree on one rule: focus on one person per trip. The other person helps find pieces in the right size and style, and if there is time left, you grab a few things for them too.

Can you buy seasonal clothes secondhand?

Yes. Holiday sweaters, cozy layers and seasonal pieces are some of the easiest things to find secondhand, and they are often worn only a few times. Try secondhand first before buying new.

What is the best thing you have ever found secondhand? Leave a comment and tell me, or share it on Instagram and tag @therawcollective.co.

Start where you are.
Lyanne

Missed Chapter 1? Read How to Shop Your Closet: The Joy of Getting Dressed Again.

Written by Lyanne Loriz, founder of RAW Collective, former fashion industry professional and mom in Miami. Read more about Lyanne here.

Continue reading

Lyanne smiling outdoors in a white cropped button-up shirt and black jeans

How to Shop Your Closet: The Joy of Getting Dressed Again

Mom and daughter in matching Human Kindness tees, a sustainable gift idea from the RAW Collective gift guide

The Buy-Less Holiday Gift Guide: Sustainable Gift Ideas They Will Actually Use

Comments

Be the first to comment.
All comments are moderated before being published.